Aaron Boone — New York Yankees
It would be an exaggeration to suggest Aaron Boone has failed as manager of the New York Yankees. After all, Boone has led the Yankees to the postseason in each of his four seasons as manager, including two 100-win seasons. In all probability, the Yankees will compete for an AL East title in ’22, with even higher goals. Having said that, it is fair to argue the Yankees have underperformed in recent years. Over the last few years, New York has had a top-two roster (Dodgers), but no World Series appearances to show for it. Boone has served as a scapegoat for a club that has yet to win the championship. The Yankees’ fans have grown tired of falling short in the postseason year after year. Boone has until October to make it happen.
Aaron Boone — New York Yankees
Scott Servais — Seattle Mariners
Scott Servais’ career as manager of the Seattle Mariners has been a roller coaster ride. When Servais took over as manager of the M’s in 2016, he inherited a club loaded with ability. However, the stoic manager watched as Seattle trimmed costs by shipping off players like Robinson Cano, Nelson Cruz, and Ketel Marte to other teams. Servais’ Mariners had gone from contender to rebuilding squad in a matter of years. Seattle surpassed all expectations in 2021 with a remarkable 90-win season. As a result, the Mariners splurged throughout the offseason, signing AL Cy Young winner Robbie Ray and power-hitting outfielder Jesse Winker. As the M’s attempt to make their first postseason appearance since 2001, all eyes will be on Servais.
Scott Servais — Seattle Mariners